Showing posts with label race. Show all posts
Showing posts with label race. Show all posts

Friday, July 20, 2018

Why Get a Lightweight Flywheel?

By Matthew Eddy - 2018-07-20

First, Ill explain why a lightweight flywheel is beneficial. Obviously, any racer knows, that reducing the weight of the vehicle is always good. In fact, nothing improves a car more than reducing weight because you can accelerate faster, stop quicker and turn harder. Basically it checks all the boxes when it comes to improving performance, so just on weight reduction alone it provides some advantage. Additionally, there is another benefit when it comes to what is called “parasitic power loss.” What this means is the engine uses some of its power to move internal components (pistons, crankshaft, etc) and driveline parts (driveshaft(s). A lot of this is unavoidable, but some of it can be reduced be eliminating as much mass in the system as possible.

They flywheel is one of the heaviest single component in the drivetrain – depending on the vehicle. It serves a few purposes such as helps to start the car, stores energy to smooth out the engine, and ease shifting by keeping the RPMs from dropping quickly (or at least that is some peoples opinion). Essentially, its to make the driving experience more pleasant. However, for a more race/performance centric car this is less of a concern and instead the focus is on speed and power. So taking this heavy flywheel out (for perspective the one in my E36 BMW weighs about 24lbs) and replacing it with a lighter one will reduce the overall weight of the car and more importantly reduce the amount of mass the engine has to turn and that means more power to the wheels.

There are a few different lightweight options available depending on the application. For lower power cars such as my stock BMW that produces 190hp, a good option is an aluminum flywheel. As I mentioned above, the stock flywheel weights 24lbs, the aluminum flywheel is only 10lbs. Now, an aluminum flywheel is not 100% aluminum, the ring gear that the starter engages will be steel, and the face the clutch will grab will be a hardened steel plate riveted or bolted on because the aluminum will just get torn up. You can see the pictures of the flywheel I just purchased for my BMW below for reference. Another claimed benefit is for some cars with dual mass flywheels, the single piece lightweight flywheel improves reliability since the dual mass flywheels can fail when you ham-fist your shifts during some spirited driving.

There is a steel plate bolted to the face of the flywheel where the clutch engages

Other side of the flywheel

Now aluminum is great but some engines produce a lot of horse power and the aluminum may not be able to stand up to it. You choose to go with something that is a bit stronger such as one made from chromoly. The weight savings are not as good but it’s still fairly significant. One for my car would be 11-14lbs (depending on brand) which is a 10-13lb weight savings over stock but still 1-4lbs heavier than the aluminum one. What is chromoly? It’s a particularly high strength steel alloy with relatively high amounts of chrome and molybdenum. It’s from Chrome and Molybdenum that the term chro-moly comes from and is designated as 4140 steel. Most flywheels are made from cast iron which isn’t particularly strong but its cheaper to make. Using high strength steel the weight savings come from the flywheel being a lot thinner and holes are added to remove additional material as well. I am not going to tell you which is best to go with, you may have to do research on your particular car and what makes the most sense for your application. Fidanza has an interesting article that you might light to read for some additional information.

https://fidanza.com/aluminum-vs-steel/


What is 6061 T6 aluminum? 

There are multiple alloys of aluminum out there but the most common “billet” type is 6061 T6. The 6061 designates the alloy, and the T6 is a reference to how it was heat treated. This allow also comes in tubes, bars, sheets etc. So pretty much any aluminum flywheel will be made with 6061 T6, but its also a very good alloy of aluminum. Billet simply means it was made from one big chunk of metal. There really is not any other way to make a flywheel, but it sounds cool to say “6061-T6 billet aluminum flywheel.”   

OK Cool But How Much POWER do I Gain?

This may vary significantly per engine and how much of a weight savings you are gaining over the stock flywheel but if the test done below is any indicator – it may be 1-2% gain in peak horse power and 2-3% gain in peak torques at the wheels. This may not seem like a lot, and its hard to say that this directly correlates, but if we say this could translate to 1-2% reduction in lap times that’s not too shabby.

http://www.superchevy.com/how-to/engines-drivetrain/1502-how-to-add-hp-with-a-lighter-flywheel-why-weight/

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

2012 F1 Driver Championship Prediction

Story by Matthew Eddy

At this point it is probably clique to mention that this season has been unpredictable with seven race winners in the first seven races (whoops to late); the top three drivers separated by only 3 points and the 4th place driver another 6 points behind that.  Considering a first place finish gains a driver 25 points the driver standings could and will change many more times in the next few races.  If the rest of the season follows the same pattern the Driver’s Championship will probably come down to a nail biting last race.

In previous seasons the front runners generally separated themselves from the pack pretty quickly.  The last few years have been anything but predictable and this season seems to have introduced a bit more volatility into the mix.  For instance I was not expecting Lotus to have such a strong car right out of the gate.  If Grosjean had finished more races he may be a contender for the championship but as it stands he is in 5th but still in striking distance.  Alonso has been driving brilliantly on a car that no one expected to be very competitive this season and had captured a crucial first place finish in Malaysia to bring him just two points shy of Hamilton in the standings.  Plus many other extraordinary drives especially by drivers a little lower in the ranks that are just starting to come into their prime.
Race number eight (of 20) is less than a week away and who knows what the outcome will be and I decided I will take the bold step of predicting the Drivers Champion before the front runners separate themselves from the pack.

Before I declare my prediction I want to assure you this has not been made on some gut feeling, or a name I pulled out of a hat.  I actually did examine some of the stats and tried to rank the drivers, cars and teams in a meaningful way.  For instance I compared drivers on their ability to qualify well regardless of penalties that may have received for gearbox changes or various other infractions.  I figure this would be a good indicator of the drivers/car abilities in relation to the rest of the field.   Also, I compared a how well a driver finished in relation to their grid position to judge whether their race pace matched their qualifying pace.   My working assumptions are that drivers who are able to qualify well are also more likely to finish well.  Most of the tope drivers, on average, will only gain or lose a few spots.  Also, I assume that team errors, mechanical failures and the like should be statistically even among teams over the course of the season though it does seem like Pastor Maldonado has had some bad luck this year with gearboxes.

So, based on looking at this data I predict that Lewis Hamilton will be the 2012 champion.   First off he is by far the best qualifying driver all season.  Of the drivers his average grid position is 2nd (keep in mind this average is based on him qualifying 1st in Spain even though he ended up starting from the back of the grid). He has consistently finished well, even if he doesn't usually translate a pole position to a first place finish.  It could be argued that this was from bad team strategy, bad pit stops or what have you, but over the course of the season all teams will make mistakes and I assume that all these will even out in the end.  A perfect example is the last race in Canada; if Alonso and Vettel had pitted right after Hamilton then they might have finished on the podium.  I have also considered the team’s ability to keep pace with car development throughout the season and McLaren-Mercedes has good track record in those regards.  One other benefit Hamilton has going for him is that he is a bit of a scrapper and tends to have his best finishes when not on pole.  Based on the races this year he had had pole position twice and both times he finished 3rd while starting from second he got a win.  Lastly he is much calmer this year and much more consistent.  

Below I have condensed some of the results so you can see them yourselves.
Here is the average grid position by each driver - WITH ALL GRID PENALTIES ERASED.  This not only includes Hamilton but Schumacher, Perez, Maldonado etc.  Hamilton has clearly done well in qualifying this season especially when compared to Alonso and Vettel.

No
Driver
Team
Avg Grid Pos*
4
Lewis Hamilton
McLaren-Mercedes
2
8
Nico Rosberg
Mercedes
5
2
Mark Webber
Red Bull Racing-Renault
5
10
Romain Grosjean
Lotus-Renault
6
1
Sebastian Vettel
Red Bull Racing-Renault
6
7
Michael Schumacher
Mercedes
7
3
Jenson Button
McLaren-Mercedes
7
5
Fernando Alonso
Ferrari
7
9
Kimi Räikkönen
Lotus-Renault
9
18
Pastor Maldonado
Williams-Renault
11
14
Kamui Kobayashi
Sauber-Ferrari
11
6
Felipe Massa
Ferrari
12
15
Sergio Perez
Sauber-Ferrari
13
11
Paul di Resta
Force India-Mercedes
13
12
Nico Hulkenberg
Force India-Mercedes
13
16
Daniel Ricciardo
STR-Ferrari
13
19
Bruno Senna
Williams-Renault
15
17
Jean-Eric Vergne
STR-Ferrari
18
20
Heikki Kovalainen
Caterham-Renault
18
21
Vitaly Petrov
Caterham-Renault
19
24
Timo Glock
Marussia-Cosworth
21
25
Charles Pic
Marussia-Cosworth
22
22
Pedro de la Rosa
HRT-Cosworth
22
23
Narain Karthikeyan
HRT-Cosworth
24

One stat I calculated was how well the driver finished compared to his grid position.  Most drivers have a positive average, meaning they tended to gain more places than they have lost averaged over the last 7 races.  However, though I did look at these figures while making my determination, I don’t think it produces very pure data.  For instance Hamilton in the Spain race gained 16 positions as he made his way from the back of the grid, but passing back markers in a car that qualified as pole is not the same as going from 16th to first.  If those 16 positions are included in his average than he on average gained 1 position per race.  If I remove this race as an anomaly, than he on average lost 1 position per race.  What muddies this even more are drivers like Vettel who may have decided not to put a few laps in during Q3 in order to save tires for the race and so he starts lower down in the field and artificially improving his average gains per race since he could have started closer to pole.  Regardless, below are the stats I have calculated without removing the Spain race from the data.  Of the top three drivers in the championship running, Alonso has had the best performance and this would partially explain how he is doing so well considering his average corrected qualifying position was 7th.

No
Driver
Team
Avg Place Change
15
Sergio Perez
Sauber-Ferrari
6.5
17
Jean-Eric Vergne
STR-Ferrari
4.4
24
Timo Glock
Marussia-Cosworth
3.7
11
Paul di Resta
Force India-Mercedes
3.0
25
Charles Pic
Marussia-Cosworth
2.8
9
Kimi Räikkönen
Lotus-Renault
2.6
23
Narain Karthikeyan
HRT-Cosworth
2.4
10
Romain Grosjean
Lotus-Renault
2.4
5
Fernando Alonso
Ferrari
2.3
12
Nico Hulkenberg
Force India-Mercedes
2.1
7
Michael Schumacher
Mercedes
1.7
4
Lewis Hamilton
McLaren-Mercedes
1.3
19
Bruno Senna
Williams-Renault
1.2
14
Kamui Kobayashi
Sauber-Ferrari
1.0
22
Pedro de la Rosa
HRT-Cosworth
1.0
1
Sebastian Vettel
Red Bull Racing-Renault
1.0
21
Vitaly Petrov
Caterham-Renault
1.0
20
Heikki Kovalainen
Caterham-Renault
0.9
18
Pastor Maldonado
Williams-Renault
0.2
6
Felipe Massa
Ferrari
-0.1
2
Mark Webber
Red Bull Racing-Renault
-0.1
16
Daniel Ricciardo
STR-Ferrari
-0.5
8
Nico Rosberg
Mercedes
-1.9
3
Jenson Button
McLaren-Mercedes
-4.4